Buylist

Sell or Trade Us Your Magic Cards

OshkoshMagic.com is now trading for and buying Magic singles. If you choose to receive Store Credit, you will receive a 10% bonus on your trade-in!

Here is how to trade in or sell your cards to us:

1. Browse through sets on the left menu to see which cards we are currently accepting. You should see a message on the top of the screen that says you are browsing to sell us cards.

2. When you have completed your trade/sell list, submit your trade using the buylist cart on the right side of the screen. We do not have a minimum buylist order amount!

3. We manually approve all buy list orders, so please do not mail your cards until receiving a final approval e-mail.

4. As soon as you receive the approval email, please mail us your cards as soon as possible. We recommend securing your cards using a hard case to avoid bending.

5. When we receive your cards, we will e-mail you confirming receipt

6. Check and PayPal payments will be sent within 7 days of receipt. If choosing PayPal, please make sure to indicate your paypal e-mail address if it is different than the one you are placing your trade with. Store credit payments will receive a 10% bonus on the trade-in price, and store credit will be issued within 2 days of receipt.

Card Condition/Language

All prices quoted are for near mint, English cards. We are only accepting English language cards at this time. Foil cards are OK, but will receive the same trade value as the non-foil version. Any cards received in less than near mint condition will have their trade value reduced depending on condition. 

Mailing Instructions

Any buylist orders received more than two weeks after being submitted may be subject to price changes depending on the market price.

Send Your Cards To:
OshkoshMagic.com
975 Freedom Ave.
Oshkosh, WI 54901-0742

If you have any questions about placing a buylist order, trading or selling us cards, or want to check on the status of your trade-in, please e-mail us and we guarantee a speedy reply!